More surveyors see prices falling: why valuers are growing cautious
Surveyors are gloomier, prices are standing perfectly still, and four in ten London flat sellers would rather not discuss what they paid.
London flats resold in the year to August went for less than the seller originally paid (e.surv).
Welcome back to The Valuation Brief. This week the people who actually stand in the hallway with a damp meter and a clipboard have had their say, and they are not feeling chipper. We have read the surveys so you do not have to.
The one-minute read
- RICS price balance: -32% in September. In August it was -28%.
- The average home costs £298,441 on the Lloyds index, which is £46 more than in August.
- Nearly four in 10 London flats resold in the past year went for less than the seller paid.
- Purchase applications fell 18.2% in the third quarter. In the second quarter the fall was 15.5%.
The surveyors have gone a bit quiet
The September RICS survey landed this morning, and four months of slowly improving mood came to a halt.
Each month RICS asks its surveyors whether prices in their area went up or down. In September, those saying “down” outnumbered those saying “up” by 32 percentage points, against 28 in August. To be clear, that is a measure of mood among surveyors, not a 32% fall in prices.
One number went the other way. New instructions rose to +6%, the first positive reading since mid-2025. More homes for sale and fewer people looking at them: you can guess who holds the cards.
Why it matters: the people filling in this survey are the same people valuing your security. When they turn cautious, agreed prices get a harder look, so expect a few more “the valuer has come in under” calls before Christmas.
£46 in a month: the market that stood still
The Lloyds House Price Index (the one most of us still call the Halifax) put the average home at £298,441 in September, against £298,395 in August. That is a rise of £46, or 0.0% however you round it. The annual change is also 0.0%, and prices are 0.2% lower over the quarter. Northern Ireland is the exception, as usual, with annual growth of 7.4%.
Lloyds calls this resilience in the face of higher mortgage rates, and reports buyer enquiries at their highest since February. RICS, as you have just read, sees enquiries falling. Not everyone is reading from the same hymn sheet.
Why it matters: a flat average hides a lot of movement underneath. A national 0.0% tells an underwriter very little about a two-bed in Croydon or a terrace in Belfast, which is why the local evidence in the report matters more than the index.
Four in 10 London flats sold for less than they cost
New repeat-sales analysis from e.surv found that nearly four in 10 London flats resold in the 12 months to August went for less than the seller originally paid. That is the highest share in Great Britain.
It is not only a London story. Around a third of flats in the South East and East of England sold at a loss, about one in five in the Midlands and the North, and just over a quarter across Great Britain. Scotland barely noticed, at fewer than one in 10. The same report has London as the only region where average prices fell over the year, down 2.3%.
Why it matters: flats are where the last purchase price is least reliable as a guide to today’s value. For remortgages, bridging exits and buy-to-let refinances on flats, “they paid more than that in 2022” is a history lesson, not a valuation.
Fewer movers, more gamblers on rates
Stonebridge’s Mortgage Market Index shows purchase applications down 18.2% on a year ago in the third quarter, worse than the 15.5% fall in the second. First-time buyer applications fell 18.6%. Remortgage applications edged up 0.8%, as the last of the pandemic-era cheap deals expire.
The average rate on Stonebridge cases was 4.92%, which is 0.55 percentage points higher than a year earlier.
In pounds: on a £250,000 mortgage over 25 years, going from 4.37% to 4.92% adds about £79 a month (our calculation).
Borrowers are responding by keeping their options open. Variable rates made up 12.5% of activity, up from 4.9% a year ago, and two-year deals took 67.5%. Few people fancy being locked in for five years at today’s prices.
Why it matters: a book full of two-year fixes and trackers is a book that comes back for a fresh valuation sooner. Brokers, your 2028 remortgage pipeline is being written now. Lenders, so is your revaluation workload.
Around the market
- Colenko completed a £570,000 bridging loan on a Woking house in 48 hours, at 75% LTV and 0.99% a month, using an AVM in place of a physical valuation. The borrower’s original lender could not make the deadline, which rather proves the point.
- Accord cut buy-to-let rates by up to 0.43% from today, taking its two-year fix at 80% LTV from 6.45% to 6.02%. On a £250,000 interest-only loan that is about £90 a month (our calculation). Someone is still competing for landlords.
- At a Countrywide Surveying Services webinar of more than 300 property professionals, 77% said they were confident homebuying reforms built around upfront property information would improve things. A further 2% said the reforms would never happen. There is always one table at the back.
When surveyors turn cautious and the indices say “flat”, what a lender needs is a clear, well-evidenced figure on the specific property, and quickly.
Have a case waiting on a valuation? Book a call with our team.
Book a callSources
- The IntermediaryHigher rate expectations weaken buyer demand in September (RICS)
- The IntermediaryHouse prices remain flat in September (Lloyds HPI)
- The IntermediaryFour in 10 London flats resold at a loss
- The IntermediaryDip in mortgage activity persists in Q3 (Stonebridge)
- The IntermediaryColenko completes £570,000 bridging loan in 48 hours
- The IntermediaryAccord cuts buy-to-let rates by up to 0.43%
- The IntermediaryEight in 10 property professionals confident in homebuying reforms
- Forbes AdvisorUK mortgage rates
Get the next edition by email
Every Tuesday and Thursday. A few minutes of market news and what it means for valuations.
You are on the list
The next edition will land in your inbox on Tuesday or Thursday.